fake treasure

Exploration Stage: Antique Store
From: Alford Stone
Description: It was a replica of a certain item that caused the witches to turn against me. I sold a crescent-shaped charm to an old woman. A reproduction, of course. She said she was interested in mysticism...a few days later, the broken charm was returned. It had to be around here somewhere. Look for it!
Completed: I guess they found the charm that caused the trouble. It was returned by mail, with no letter of any kind in it. The old woman didn't even ask for a refund. Suspicious, isn't it? That's when I started noticing all sorts of other suspicious signs. They were getting scarier and scarier.