Fake Treasure

Exploration Stage: Antique Store
From: Alford Stone
Description: The witches turned against me because of one particular fake. I sold an old lady a crescent charm. A copy, of course. The lady said that she was fond of the occult sciences... A few days later, she returned the charm broken. It’s here somewhere, help me find it!
Completed: Thank you for finding the broken charm that caused all of my misery. It came in the mail without a covering letter. The lady didn’t even demand her money back. An alarming sign! Soon, I began to notice other signs, which were more and more frightening.